Para ver este documento en
español, oprima aquí.
Keep Base, Lose Live Fire
July 17, 1999
Copyright © 1999 ORLANDO SENTINEL. All Rights Reserved.
Arrogance. That sums up the U.S. Navy's response to complaints
about live bombings at a U.S. base on the Puerto Rican island
Navy Secretary Richard Danzig this week unveiled an internal
review's results. To no one's surprise, he underscored the base's
significance, calling it one of a kind. But then he announced
that the Navy must use real explosives during training on Vieques,
that no alternative exists.
The Navy's position suggests little interest in compromise.
It essentially slaps Puerto Ricans -- especially Vieques residents
-- in the face. Popular criticism of the base has increased since
debris from an errant bomb killed a civilian guard and wounded
others in April.
Puerto Ricans worry -- rightfully -- that more accidents could
happen, especially with thousands of people living just a few
miles from the testing area. Civilians shouldn't be exposed to
Puerto Ricans have banded together to ask the Navy to stop
using real explosives. The Navy temporarily suspended live-ammunition
tests. But now it seems as though the brass plans to resume those
That would force Puerto Rico to walk away from that contentious
issue with nothing but a promise from the Navy to scale back the
use of live ammunition.
Oh, the Navy also tossed Vieques a bone, offering to beef up
its economic-development efforts on the island. That almost goes
without saying, given how much land the Navy controls on Vieques.
It plays a key role in the island's economy.
The Navy should soften its stance. Otherwise, it risks perpetual
hostility over Vieques.
Tensions stemming from the training have intensified to the
point that many Puerto Ricans want the Navy to get out altogether.
That wouldn't make sense, because Vieques plays such a vital
role in U.S. national security. All branches of the U.S. military
train there. It has helped to hone the Navy's skills before every
major conflict since World War II. The base and surrounding areas
offer a unique combination of accessible training with consistently
But surely training can continue without endangering Vieques'
civilians. Most of the testing on the island already uses nonexplosive
ammunition. The Navy should increase that to 100 percent and find
uninhabited areas to conduct tests using real explosives.
That's an acceptable compromise.