Esta página no está disponible en español.
New Year's Eve Injuries Caused by Celebratory Gunfire --- Puerto Rico, 2003 Americans Urged To Leave The Guns Locked Up On New Year's Eve, Says Brady Campaign To Prevent Gun Violence
New Year's Eve Injuries Caused by Celebratory Gunfire --- Puerto Rico, 2003
December 24, 2004
Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
Vol. 53, Issue No. 50
Bullets fired into the air during celebrations fall with sufficient force to cause injury and death (1). However, few data exist regarding the epidemiology of injuries related to celebratory gunfire. In Puerto Rico, where such celebratory actions are common, news media reports have indicated that approximately two persons die and an estimated 25 more are injured each year from celebratory gunfire on New Year's Eve. The Puerto Rico Department of Health (PRDOH) invited CDC and local law enforcement agencies to assist in the investigation of injuries resulting from celebratory gunfire that occurred during December 31, 2003--January 1, 2004. This report summarizes the findings of that investigation, which determined that 1) bullets from probable celebratory gunfire caused 19 injuries, including one death and 2) such injuries affected a higher percentage of women and children aged [lesser than] 15 years than injuries from noncelebratory gunfire, with the majority occurring in certain public housing areas in densely populated, metropolitan San Juan. Education and enforcement of existing laws are needed to prevent these injuries.
A probable celebratory gunfire injury was defined as an unintentional firearm injury (International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision codes W32--W34 ) inflicted outdoors by an unidentified assailant during the 48-hour period beginning 12 a.m., December 31, 2003, and ending 11: 59 p.m., January 1, 2004. Available information regarding the injury or event had to be consistent with the return trajectory of a bullet fired into the air. Cases were identified from newspaper and law enforcement reports and hospital and medical examiner records. For persons who sustained injuries from celebratory gunfire, information was collected on age, sex, time of injury, injury severity, body location of injury, and geographic location where the injury occurred. Age and sex information were also collected for persons who sustained injuries from noncelebratory gunfire that occurred during the study period.
During the 2-day period, 43 persons were injured by gunfire. Of these injuries, 28 (65%) were identified as unintentional; 19 (68%) of those met the case definition for probable celebratory gunfire injuries. Median age of the 19 persons injured from celebratory gunfire was 24 years (range: 4 months--82 years); 12 (63%) were male. Four (21%) persons were hospitalized, including one who died from a head injury. The most common body location for injury from celebratory gunfire was the head (36%), followed by foot (26%) and shoulder (16%) (Figure 1).
Of the 19 injuries, 18 (95%) occurred in metropolitan San Juan; 14 (78%) occurred among persons in 10 of the city's 51 public housing areas. Four public housing areas accounted for eight (42%) cases. Eight (42%) injuries occurred during 6 p.m.--10 p.m. on December 31, 2003, and nine (47%) injuries occurred between 10 p.m. on December 31, 2003, and 2 a.m. on January 1, 2004.
The sex and age of the 19 persons with a probable celebratory gunfire injury were compared with the sex and age of 24 other persons with a noncelebratory gunfire injury. Seven (37%) persons who sustained injuries from celebratory gunfire were female, compared with three (13%) females among 24 persons with injuries from noncelebratory gunfire. Four (21%) persons who sustained injuries from celebratory gunfire were children aged [lesser than] 15 years; no injuries from noncelebratory gunfire occurred among this age group (Figure 2).
Reported by: I Rodriguez, MS, B Mirabal-Colon, MD, Center for Hispanic Youth Violence Prevention, School of Medicine, Univ of Puerto Rico, San Juan; J Alonso-Echanove, MD, C Rodriguez, MS, J Rullan, MD, Puerto Rico Dept of Health. A Crosby, MD, I Arias, PhD, Div of Violence Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control; F Alvarado-Ramy, MD, Epidemiology Program Office; V Balaban, PhD, B Cauthen, MD, EIS officers, CDC.
When fired into the air, bullets can return to the ground at speeds greater than 200 ft./sec., a sufficient force to penetrate the human skull and cause serious injury or death (1). News media reports from around the world suggest that celebratory gunfire injuries might be a widespread public health problem; however, further data are needed to determine the extent of the problem. The data presented in this report indicate that bullets from probable celebratory gunfire caused 19 injuries, including one death, during December 31, 2003--January 1, 2004, in Puerto Rico. These injuries primarily occurred at midnight on December 31 in a limited number of public housing areas. Celebratory gunfire injuries affected a high percentage of children and females, populations not typically at high risk for such injuries. These findings are consistent with a previous study of celebratory gunfire injuries in a metropolitan area (1).
Firearm-related injuries are a significant public health concern in Puerto Rico. In 2001, a total of 738 deaths were attributed to firearm injuries, a rate of 19.2 per 100,000 population, which is substantially higher than the U.S. national rate (10.4) and higher than the rates for all U.S. states (3). The celebratory gunfire injuries described in this report represent a small but preventable proportion of firearm injuries in Puerto Rico.
The findings in this report are subject to at least three limitations. First, no standards exist for defining cases of celebratory gunfire injuries. For example, the "lost bullet" classification used by Puerto Rico law enforcement does not differentiate between falling bullets and stray bullets. The data sources used in this study were not developed for identifying celebratory gunfire injuries and provided limited context information, preventing definitive confirmation of falling bullet trajectory for some injuries. In addition, law enforcement records did not record injury severity, and not all medical records contained adequate information to determine injury severity; therefore, injury severity was not analyzed. Second, the lack of electronic databases containing records for previous years limited evaluation of possible trends. Finally, no information was available regarding persons who used firearms, and no direct information was available from victims and witnesses, who might have provided information about the circumstances of the injuries.
To limit celebratory gunfire, in 2002, the Puerto Rico legislature increased penalties for reckless discharge of firearms. In addition, previous prevention efforts by PRDOH included a public awareness campaign advising residents to remain indoors from 11 p.m. on New Year's Eve to 2 a.m. on New Year's Day (J. Alonso, MD, PRDOH, personal communication, 2004). PRDOH, in collaboration with local law enforcement and the Puerto Rico Departments of Family, Housing, and Education, is participating in a multi-agency prevention effort for New Year's Eve 2004 to reduce celebratory gunfire injuries.
On the basis of this study, investigators made several recommendations to the Puerto Rico Ministry of Health. First, existing laws against celebratory gunfire should be actively enforced. Second, PRDOH, in collaboration with community leaders of public housing areas, should develop a campaign focused on changing attitudes and behaviors toward celebratory gunfire in these areas. Third, to minimize the risk for injury from celebratory gunfire, residents should remain indoors from 6 p.m. on New Year's Eve to 2 a.m. on New Year's Day. Finally, to more accurately monitor these and other injuries over time, an emergency department--based injury surveillance system should be implemented.
The findings in this report are based, in part, on contributions by A Correo, V Colon, P Fuentes, Puerto Rico Police Dept; J Acosta, MD, N Almodovar, M Ayala Molina, Medical Svcs Admin; M Conte, MD, Puerto Rico Forensic Institute; M Franco Ortiz, PhD, J Rivera, MD, Center for Hispanic Youth Violence Prevention, School of Medicine, Univ of Puerto Rico, San Juan..
* Ordog GJ, Dornhoffer P, Ackroyd G, et al. Spent bullets and their injuries: the result of firing weapons into the sky. J Trauma 1994;37: 1003--6.
* World Health Organization. International statistical classification of diseases and related health problem, tenth revision. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 1992.
* CDC. Deaths: final data for 2001. Natl Vital Stat Rep 2003;52(3).
See original document at http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/weekcvol.html for image of Figure 1
See original document at http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/weekcvol.html for image of Figure 2
Americans Urged To Leave The Guns Locked Up On New Year's Eve, Says Brady Campaign To Prevent Gun Violence
December 28, 2004
WASHINGTON, Dec. 28 /U.S. Newswire/ -- In dozens of American communities this New Year's Eve, overexcited and under- intelligent individuals will welcome 2005 with an act of stupidity. They may kill an innocent in the bargain, too.
The Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence and the Million Mom March are joining with America's police departments to urge Americans not to engage in what police call "celebratory gunfire" -- the indiscriminate unloading of weapons into the air. On New Year's Eve and Independence Day each year, scores of people place others at risk of injury or death as a result of celebratory gunfire. When a bullet is fired into the air, the bullet has to come down somewhere.
The practice of celebratory gunfire has been a problem in cities like Miami, New Orleans, Phoenix and Los Angeles and in towns along the U.S. and Mexico border. Last year, it became such a problem in Puerto Rico that U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention were called in for advice.
"Every police group in America supports national and local efforts to educate citizens on the dangers of celebratory gunfire," said John Shanks, Law Enforcement Relations Director for Brady and the Million Moms. "Every police officer in America would urge people not to do something as reckless as this."
"It makes no sense whatsoever to fire a weapon into the air, not knowing where the bullet may fall. This is probably the most unsafe, crazy practice people engage in on New Year's Eve," said Steve Lenkart of the International Brotherhood of Police Officers. And Curt Lavarello, Executive Director for the National Association of School Resource Officers said, "It would be horrific if one of our students did not return to school after the winter break because of this type of reckless behavior with firearms."
Four years ago, Phoenix, Arizona enacted Shannon's Law, in memory of 14-year-old Shannon Smith, killed by a stray bullet in June 1999 while talking on her phone in her back yard. The law makes it a felony to fire a gun into the air within the city limits. Yet in 2003, there were still 95 cases of random gunfire successfully prosecuted in the city of Phoenix.
How dangerous can it get? Consider one of the risks facing America's service men and women in Iraq. Last November, celebratory gunfire in Baghdad following the death of Saddam Hussein's two sons cost 31 Iraqis their lives, including two young children. Seventy- six others were wounded.
Contact: Anne Rosello of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, 202-898-0792